Sunday, October 25, 2020 | ePaper

Babri demolition case: LK Advani, 31 others acquitted; no local testified

  • Print
Hindustan Times, Lucknow :
The special CBI court in Lucknow on Wednesday acquitted all 32 accused, including former deputy prime minister LK Advani, former union minister Murli Manohar Joshi, ex-Rajasthan governor Kalyan Singh and former Madhya Pradesh chief minister Uma Bharti, in the Babri Masjid demolition case due to lack of conclusive evidence.
Ruling out the criminal conspiracy theory, the court held that the demolition on December 6, 1992 was a spontaneous act and not pre-planned.
Ending a nearly 28-year wait in less than 28 minutes, judge SK Yadav delivered the verdict around 12.15am. He held that the prosecution (CBI) could not establish the role of the 32 accused (now acquitted) with regard to the evidence (points) it had submitted in court during the proceedings. The verdict came nearly 11 months after the Supreme Court, in November last year, paved the way for building a Ram temple at the very site in Ayodhya where the masjid once stood.
It observed that none of the locals of Ayodhya testified against any of the accused to prove that they incited the mob.
"The CBI court has acquitted all the 32 accused in the Babri Masjid case. This ends the long pending dispute related to the December 6, 1992 case," confirmed lawyer KK Mishra, who represented 25 accused in the court, including Advani, Joshi and Kalyan Singh, who was the UP chief minister at the time of the demolition.
"The court observed that the December 6, 1992 incident wasn't planned and that it was a spontaneous act," the lawyer said.
The judge did not admit the videos produced by the CBI as they were not certified (tested) in the forensic laboratory to ascertain their authenticity.
Photographs submitted were also not accepted as the agency could not produce the original negatives, another defence lawyer Manish Tripathi said.
Of the total 49 accused in the case, 17 had died. Twenty-six of the remaining 32 accused arrived in person at the court when the judge delivered the verdict. Advani was present via video link.
There were intelligence reports, the court said, at the time indicating that some anti-social elements might indulge in some unwarranted act.
It said that witness (number 9) Anju Gupta had given a statement in court that some 'dacoits and criminals' also mingled with the crowd of kar sevaks. Anju Gupta was additional superintendent of police, posted in Ayodhya during the time the incident took place.
The court observed that at noon on December 6, 1992 in Ayodhya, everything was fine. Then, some anti-social elements started brick-batting from behind the structure (Babri Masjid), it said.
It also pointed out that Ashok Singhal (late VHP leader) was appealing to kar sevaks not to indulge in violence and only carry out kar seva as per guidelines of the Supreme Court.
The judge who pronounced the verdict was on a year's extension and his extended term ended today.
A ceremony to mark the beginning of the construction of Ram temple was held on August 5 and attended by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
The Supreme Court had in November, while maintaining that the demolition was a 'criminal act', ordered that an alternative land be provided to the Sunni Waqf Board for a mosque within Ayodhya.
The CBI will decide on filing an appeal against the special court verdict acquitting all 32 accused in the Babri Masjid demolition case after consulting the legal department, its counsel said on Wednesday.
"After a copy of today's verdict is received, it would be sent to the CBI headquarters where it would be studied by the legal department and a decision on filing an appeal would be taken as per its suggestion," CBI counsel Lalit Singh said.
Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath welcomed the court verdict, terming it as Satyamev Jayate (victory of truth), according to a statement issued by his advisor Mritunjay Kumar.
Adityanath also spoke with BJP veterans LK Advani and MM Joshi over phone and congratulated them on the verdict.
Reacting to the court's verdict, Iqbal Ansari, a prominent litigant in the Ayodhya title suit case, said: "The entire world saw what happened in Ayodhya (on December 6, 1992). I respect the court's verdict."
Ansari had issued an appeal to the CBI court earlier this month, requesting to close the case and acquit all 32 accused in larger interest of the nation and Hindu-Muslim unity.
"We abided by the SC verdict in November last year and we would abide by the latest decision again. There is no question of opposing it. Ayodhya wants peace," Ansari said.
Mohsin Raza, a minister in the UP government, welcomed the verdict. In an interview to HT on July 30, former chief minister Kalyan Singh, whose government was dismissed after the December 6, 1992 demolition, had said that he was proud of the fact that he refused to allow firing on kar sevaks (religious volunteers) who had gathered in Ayodhya.
"I am proud of the fact that I didn't allow firing. I also feel that it was the demolition that paved the way for the Ram temple," Kalyan had said. An accused in the demolition, Kalyan, infected with the coronavirus, couldn't make it to the court.

More News For this Category

US scientists find country's first 'murder hornet' nest

Al Jazeera News :Scientists in the northwest United States have located the country's first nest of Asian giant hornets, otherwise known as "murder hornets".In a statement on Friday, the

At least six children killed in attack on Cameroonian school

Reuters, Kumba :Gunmen killed at least six children and badly wounded about eight others when they stormed a school in Cameroon's Anglophone South West Region on Saturday and opened

Turkish President Erdogan says French counterpart Macron needs 'mental checks'

AFP :Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Saturday slammed his French counterpart, Emmanuel Macron, over his policies toward Muslims, saying that he needed "mental checks."Macron and Erdogan are feuding

NASA probe leaking asteroid samples due to jammed door

Al Jazeera News :A US probe that collected a sample from an asteroid earlier this week retrieved so much material that a rock is wedged in the container door,

In separate drives, DB police arrest 6 persons along with counterfeit money worth Tk. 58 lakh and devices from Kotwali, Adabar and other parts in the capital on Saturday.

In separate drives, DB police arrest 6 persons along with counterfeit money worth Tk. 58 lakh and devices from Kotwali, Adabar and other parts in the capital on Saturday.


Chief Justice Syed A. B. Mahmud Husain and senior lawyers of Supreme Court  attend the Namaz-e-Janaza of veteran lawyer Barrister Rafique-Ul Huq held on Supreme Court Premises on Saturday.

Chief Justice Syed A. B. Mahmud Husain and senior lawyers of Supreme Court attend the Namaz-e-Janaza of veteran lawyer Barrister Rafique-Ul Huq held on Supreme Court Premises on Saturday.


Auto-promotion a ploy to ruin education system: Speakers

Staff Reporter :Speakers at a discussion meeting on Saturday expressed their deep anxiety over the government's decision of giving students auto-promotion without holding examinations.They said, auto-pass instead of HSC

About 1,094 new virus cases, deaths 19 :Bangladesh has posted 1,094 new cases of the novel coronavirus infection in a daily count, taking the tally so far to 397,507.The death toll climbed to 5,780 after

Barrister Rafique-Ul Huq laid to rest

News DeskĀ  :Noted jurist Barrister Rafique-Ul Huq was laid to eternal rest at Banani graveyard in Dhaka on Saturday afternoon.He was buried around 3:00pm after a namaz-e-janaza at Supreme

Former RU student found dead in Savar

Staff Reporter :A former student of Rajshahi University was found dead by Dhaka-Aricha highway in Savar on Saturday morning.The deceased was identified as Mostafizur Rahman (29), son of Khabir