Thursday, January 23, 2020 | ePaper

Unconstitutional India's New Citizenship Act

  • Print
Debarati Guha :
Indian citizenship has always been firmly rooted in the country's Constitution, which emphasizes equality, regardless of gender, caste, religion, class, community or language.  
The recently approved Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAB) does exactly the opposite. It violates every one of these fundamental values and spreads the wings of "Hindutva," or Hindu nationalism, in this so-called secular country by making religion the key to citizenship.
This unconstitutional act also violates and shreds the provisions in the Indian constitution that guarantee citizens' right to equality, equality before the law and non-discriminatory treatment by the Indian state.
The legislation - which alters the Citizenship Act of 1955 - tears down the inclusive, composite vision that guided India's struggle to gain freedom from British colonial rule. It grants an expedited path to Indian citizenship for people facing persecution in Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Pakistan only if they are not Muslim.
These people can be Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis, Christians and, of course, Hindus. But no Muslims - even if they are persecuted minorities like the Rohingya from Myanmar or Ahmadiyyas from Pakistan.
Discriminating against Muslims
What's the rationale for this exclusion? Are Muslims any less human or facing less brutality in these countries?
One could say that this is the first successful attempt, by statute, to exclude Muslims from the possibility of amnesty and Indian citizenship - for no reason other than religion.
After winning the last general election, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has made it abundantly clear that it is willing to ignore the Muslim community.
Even the Supreme Court of India recently awarded a disputed site in the town of Ayodhya to a government-run trust for the construction of a temple to the Hindu god Ram. The disputed land was the site of the 16th-century Babri Masjid mosque, which was razed by angry Hindu mobs in 1992 claiming that a Ram temple predated the mosque.
The Archaeological Survey of India could not prove if there had been a Hindu structure at the site. Nevertheless, the top court granted the land to the "big brother" and told the bullied "little brother" to play somewhere else.
New law in India grants citizenship to religious minorities
Even though Indian Home Minister Amit Shah says CAB will be implemented separately from the proposed nationwide implementation of the National Register of Citizens (NRC), in my opinion, both should be viewed in the same light. If the Indian Parliament can pass CAB, then what will stop them from passing the NRC?
The NRC in the northeastern state of Assam has already excluded nearly 2 million people from Indian citizenship. This has demonstrated the terrible human costs of dividing people and linking citizenship to documentation in a country where many people are illiterate and lack the proper papers.
Persecuted people have suffered atrocities, broken families and statelessness, among other hardships. It's also true for Muslims.
Religion for political gains
So why is there no dissent in India? Of course, there have been protests and demonstrations.
Many intellectuals as well as ordinary people have criticized and taken to the streets in protest. But has the criticism influenced lawmakers? Clearly it hasn't.
The new citizenship act shows us that India needs a refugee policy in line with international law, and not a law based on discrimination and dictated by an ideology that makes use of religion for political gains.
CAB will surely unleash widespread division and suffering among people, rather than addressing critical needs of the people - from food security and employment to the elimination of discrimination based on caste, religion and gender.
Unfortunately, it will now become law, as both houses of Parliament have passed the measure. Surprisingly, it was approved in the legislature's upper house - the Rajya Sabha - where the BJP doesn't even enjoy a majority.
If things continue at this pace, it will not be long before the fundamental pluralistic character of India is altered.

(Debarati Guha, head of DW, Asia Service) 

More News For this Category

Nobody is there to control them

CHHATRA League activists of Dhaka University's Sergeant Zahurul Haq Hall are at it again as they tortured four students for nearly three hours before handing them to police early Tuesday.

Bad loan culture ruining banking sector's future

FINANCE Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal in a bold statement in Parliament on Wednesday disclosed that 8,238 loan defaulters owed Tk 96,986.38 crore to various public and private banks till November

Coronavirus What Makes World Worry

Ifeanyi Nsofor :The coronavirus outbreak - which began in Wuhan, China, and causes a pneumonia-like illness - is raging across Asia, infecting close to 300 people and killing four. It

Killing Soleimani Undermines Global Order

Alon Ben-Meir :Those who applaud the assassination of General Soleimani seem to simply equate him to a terrorist who certainly deserved to meet his fate. The question here is not

Who dares to catch the untouchable drug dons

DESPITE taking different preventive measures, the number of drug addicts is increasing alarmingly. About 114 drug addicts on an average take treatment every day at public and private rehabilitation centers.

Govt faces hard time for needless expenditures coupled with corruption

THE Finance Ministry has asked all ministries and divisions not to seek additional fund in the current fiscal year in a signal that the government is tightening its belt amid

Agriculture And Moroccan Rural Development

Yossef Ben-Meir:In recent years, Morocco has put in place the right frameworks for mobilizing rural communities to advance the nation's sustainable development goals, yet it falls woefully short when it

Microteaching A Modern Teaching Technique

Gazi Md. Abdur Rashid :Micro-teaching is defined as a system of controlled practice that makes it possible to concentrate on specified teaching behavior and to practice teaching under controlled conditions.

BSTI shatters people's trust

THE Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution destroyed all the evidences relating to the prosecution of 61 companies accused of marketing 73 uneatable packaged food items last year. A Dhaka Court

Custodial death goes as worst kind of disregard for law

ABU BAKAR Siddique Babu was arrested around 8:00pm on Saturday by Tejgaon Industrial Police. Later he was found hanging from the iron bars of a lockup room of the same