Monday, October 21, 2019 | ePaper

UK parliament may be recalled if suspension ruled unlawful

  • Print
LONDON (Reuters) :
Boris Johnson could recall parliament if Britain's highest court rules he unlawfully suspended it, a government lawyer said on Tuesday, after judges heard the prime minister wanted a shutdown because it was an obstacle to his Brexit plans.
Johnson announced on Aug. 28 that he had asked Queen Elizabeth to prorogue, or suspend, parliament for five weeks from last week until Oct. 14. He said the shutdown was necessary to allow him to introduce a new legislative agenda.
Opponents said the real reason was to prevent scrutiny and challenges by parliament - where he now has no majority - to his Brexit policy, especially his promise to leave the European Union by Oct. 31 even if no divorce deal has been agreed.
They want the Supreme Court, the United Kingdom's highest judicial body, to rule Johnson's actions were illegal. Critics, including rebels thrown out of his Conservative Party over Brexit, say he should resign if that is its decision.
"The consequence (of his advice to the monarch being ruled unlawful) could be that he goes to the queen and seeks the recall of parliament," Richard Keen, the government's chief law officer in Scotland, told the court.
In a damning judgment last Wednesday, Scotland's highest court said the suspension  was unlawful and an "egregious" attempt to stymie parliament.
However, a week earlier the High Court of England and Wales rejected a similar case, saying the matter was political and not something judges should interfere in.
All 11 judges on the Supreme Court will now decide on a crucial question: how far Britain's unwritten constitution limits the power of the prime minister and whether Johnson's advice to the queen was therefore illegal.
"That this is a serious and difficult question of law is amply demonstrated by the fact that three senior judges in Scotland have reached a different conclusion from three senior judges in England and Wales," said Brenda Hale, president of the Supreme Court.
Launching the legal challenge to Johnson's decision - by a mixture of anti-Brexit campaigners and opposition lawmakers - David Pannick said there was strong evidence the prime minister wanted to silence parliament because he saw it as an obstacle.
No premier had abused the prorogation power in this way for at least 50 years, he told the court.
"The prime minister advised Her Majesty to prorogue parliament for a period as long as five weeks because he, the prime minister, wished to avoid what he saw as the risk that parliament would take action to frustrate or damage the policies of his government," Pannick said.
He said it was "remarkable" Johnson had not provided a witness statement spelling out his reasons for the prorogation and that the court could therefore draw adverse inference from his failure to do so.
Johnson has said the current session of parliament was longer than any since the English Civil war in the 17th century, and that lawmakers would have plenty of time to discuss Brexit again after an EU summit on Oct. 17-18.
When asked on Friday if he had misled the queen, Johnson said: "Absolutely not".
In a television interview broadcast on Tuesday, Johnson said he had the greatest respect for the judiciary but declined to say whether he would recall parliament if the ruling goes against the government.
"I think the best thing that I can do is wait and see what the judges say," he told the BBC.
Keen said the prime minister would "respond by all necessary means" to any declaration by the court that the advice Johnson gave to the queen was illegal. But asked by one judge if Johnson might seek another suspension, he said: "I'm not in a position to comment on that."
The government says opponents of Brexit are using the courts to try to frustrate Britain's departure from the bloc which was approved in a 2016 referendum.
But Pannick said the matter was not about how or if Brexit took place but to establish that the executive, the government, was the junior partner to parliament. "The basic principle is that parliament is supreme," he said.
The Supreme Court ruled against the government in a similar constitutional case in 2017 when it said ministers could not begin the formal two-year exit process without the approval of parliament. Its hearings will run until Thursday, with the verdict not expected until Friday at the earliest.
"It is important to emphasize that we are not concerned with the wider political issues which form the context for this legal issue," Hale said.
"The determination of this legal issue will not determine when and how the United Kingdom leaves the European Union."


More News For this Category

Mayhem over Facebook post on Prophet (SM) in Bhola

Mayhem over Facebook post on Prophet (SM) in Bhola

Staff Reporter :At least four people were reportedly killed and many others injured as locals, who were protesting over an "unverified Facebook post", clashed with police in Borhanuddin upazila of

DNCC Councillor Rajib expelled from JL

DNCC Councillor Rajib expelled from JL

Staff Reporter :Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC) Ward Councillor Tarequzzaman Rajib has been expelled from Jubo League (JL) for breaching organization's discipline.JL General Secretary Harunur Rashid confirmed the matter to

DIG Prisons Rashid sent to jail

DIG Prisons Rashid sent to jail

A Dhaka court on Sunday sent Deputy Inspector General (DIG) of prisons Md Bazlur Rashid to jail in a graft case.Acting Judge Al Mamun Bhuiyan of Dhaka Metropolitan Sessions Judge

MP Bubly expelled from Open University

MP Bubly expelled from Open University

Staff Reporter :Bangladesh Open University (BOU) has expelled Tamanna Nusrat Bubly MP permanently and cancelled her all examinations and registration on charge of adopting unfair means in her BA examinations

Don't allow further loan to defaulters

Staff Reporter :The High Court on Sunday ordered the Bangladesh Bank and other banks not to allow the loan defaulters to take out fresh credit for one more month or

DNCC Ward Councillor Rajib arrested

Staff Reporter :As part of the ongoing anti-Casino drive, Rapid Action Battalion arrested Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC) Councillor of Ward No 33 Tariquzzaman Rajib from a residence at Boshundhara

We have a role model govt for protection of corruption and crime

Dhaka City Corporations repeatedly conducted drives to evict the hawkers from the footpaths and other forbidden areas but they returned to the spaces within hours. The eviction drives rather

 Soaring prices hit common people hard

Soaring prices hit common people hard

Al Amin :The soaring prices of essential commodities are causing huge sufferings to the low and middle- income groups of people throughout the country.The price of onion is the highest,

Police charge batons and dispersed two groups of BCL students engaged in clashes in front of Patharghata Awami League office at Barguna leaving 30 people injured following the expulsion of BCL General Secretary Enamul Hossain as intruder. This photo was taken on Saturday.

Police charge batons and dispersed two groups of BCL students engaged in clashes in front of Patharghata Awami League office at Barguna leaving 30 people injured following the expulsion of BCL General Secretary Enamul Hossain as intruder. This photo was taken on Saturday.

UN HQs to remain closed in the weekend due to budget crunch

ANI, Washington :The United Nations Headquarters in New York will remain closed in the forthcoming weekend due to the ongoing cash crisis."The UNHQ buildings in NYC will be closed on