Tuesday, November 19, 2019 | ePaper

Reading Printed Text

Students retain more from hard copy

  • Print


Shawna De La Rosa :
Despite the availability and cost savings of digital texts, studies indicate that students absorb more information when reading text on paper rather than on screens, according to The Hechinger Report. The most recent analysis was conducted by Virginia Clinton, an assistant professor of education at the University of North Dakota.
Her results indicate that retention after reading printed text improves more than a fifth of a standard deviation. This finding is at odds with many districts' plans to move into a fully digital environment. Digital textbooks are gaining popularity because they save environmental resources and money.
Spending on curriculum materials and textbooks has decreased as more digital textbooks are becoming available. However, the growing evidence beg the question of whether or not those cost savings are worth it the risk of not retaining as much information.
Moving textbooks from print to digital formats makes sense financially. Many districts are moving towards a "paper-free" environment and that includes curriculum materials. Unfortunately, mounting evidence indicates that performance drops when students learn on a screen.
Though there are economic and environmental reasons to be paper-free, research finds that scrolling tends to have a disruptive effect on students' comprehension.
Lauren Singer, a doctoral candidate at the University of Maryland (UM), says that reading on a computer screen requires a different set of skills than reading text on paper. Working with UM Professor Patricia Alexander, Singer found that readers don't comprehend long text as well when it is read digitally.
Singer suggests that educators train students to slow down while reading digitally in an effort to improve their comprehension. She also suggests educators train students to answer questions about the content after each chapter.
Clinton recommends giving students the choice between using digital or printed materials. Some students consider digital reading as a more casual setting for social media. Printed textbooks command more respect so students will often put forth more effort when reading the printed material.
(Courtesy: educationdive.com).

More News For this Category

What's Wrong with Debates

What's Wrong with Debates

Zoe Weil  :It's debate season in the U.S.Televised debates are one of the primary ways citizens evaluate presidential candidates. But because it is virtually impossible to offer well-articulated, honest

Struggle for Learning

Struggle for Learning

Lydia Denworth :When children are learning to read, teachers often suggest a rule for picking an appropriate book. Count the words on the page that you don't know. Five

Working Mothers and Their Children

Working Mothers and Their Children

Tangina Sultana :Working mothers are the ones who move out of the house forthe purpose ofearning money and also maintain household chores.Mother's job is so challenging. Shehas to manage

Screen-Time and Academic Performance

Screen-Time and Academic Performance

Campus Desk :Today's young people are immersed in a digital world that most of us couldn't imagine a decade ago. Because technology is evolving so quickly, it's difficult to

Real approach in teaching English a must

Real approach in teaching English a must

Md. Humayun Kabir Bhuiyan :Teaching English is felt highly important especially at primary level for many educational reasons. The researchers are of the view that educational objectives will remain

An ideal learning environment in School

An ideal learning environment in School

Tangina Sultana :School life is considered the best period of human life. People learn from his childhood in the school and also the character of man is built in

Moral Degradation

Moral Degradation

Mohammad Mamun Mia :Moral degradation or breakdown is a phenomenon in which a major degradation or complete loss of moral values takes place. The morals and values which are

From Bangladesh to the UK: A FameLabber's journey

From Bangladesh to the UK: A FameLabber's journey

Abu Saleh Muhammed Afrin Bin Nur (Adib) :For someone who loves both science and public speaking, when I first came to know about FameLab, I knew I had to

Writing a Personal Statement

Writing a Personal Statement

Glenn Geher :Like it or not, you'll be writing personal statements (sometimes referred to as a "statement of purpose") pretty much throughout your adult life. I bet that some

World Poverty Day

World Poverty Day

Rashmita S. Mistry, Ph.D :A few years back, while driving around Los Angeles, my then 4-year-old son asked me to read a sign held by a panhandler on a