Wednesday, November 13, 2019 | ePaper

Kulbhushan Jadhav

UN court orders Pakistan to review Indian 'spy' death sentence

  • Print
DW News :
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ordered Pakistan to review the death penalty for the former Indian navy commander. New Delhi had complained of an unfair trial and sought the ICJ's intervention.
The Hague-based International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled Wednesday that Pakistan violated the consular rights to Kulbhushan Sudhir Jadhav and must review the death sentence of the alleged Indian spy.
The tribunal in The Hague ordered an "effective review and reconsideration of the conviction and sentence of Mr Kulbhushan Sudhir Jadhav," according to a document on the court's website.
India hailed the ICJ ruling as a "complete victory."
"By ordering Pakistan to follow the Vienna Convention this is a complete victory for us. This opens up the possibility of consular access and a retrial in a civilian court," an Indian government official said, adding that "if Pakistan wants improved relations it should set him free and give him safe passage back to us."
"The ICJ in its judgment announced today regarding Indian serving Naval Commander Kulbhushan Jadhav has decided not to acquit/release him… Having heard the judgment, Pakistan will now proceed as per law," Pakistan's foreign office said in a statement on Wednesday.
Pakistan arrested Jadhav, a former Indian naval officer, in March 2016. Islamabad claims that Jadhav confessed to a Pakistani military court that he had been tasked by India's Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) intelligence agency to "plan, coordinate, and organize espionage/sabotage activities aiming to destabilize and wage war against Pakistan" in the southwestern province of Baluchistan and the southern port city of Karachi.
In April, 2017, a military court sentenced Jadhav to death, a verdict that angered Indian authorities, who believe that if the ruling was carried out, it would substantially damage ties between the two nuclear-armed countries.
Eventually, New Delhi sought the intervention of the ICJ, which ordered Islamabad not to execute the Indian national until it passes final judgment in the case.
India insists Jadhav was wrongly convicted for spying in a "farcical trial." At the UN court, India's legal team focused its arguments on Pakistan denying Jadhav access to legal counsel and consular access, and refusing to reveal the charges or evidence against him. In so doing, it stated that the Pakistani government had committed "egregious violations of the Vienna convention" and "deprived" the Indian national of his rights and protection accorded under the international treaty.
Pakistan countered the arguments by saying that it met all its international treaty obligations. It also maintained that the ICJ did not have jurisdiction to hear the Indian petition.
Jadhav's death sentence also turned international focus on Pakistan's military justice system. Activists deride them for their "extra-constitutional" character. Rights groups say under the military court system, civilian defendants are barred from hiring their own lawyers, media outlets are not allowed to observe proceedings, there is no right to appeal, and the military tribunal judges - who do not necessarily hold law degrees - are not required to provide reasons for their verdict.

More News For this Category

Saudi govt. must punish their own people who are brutal with Bangladeshi maids

The latest tragic story of Sumi Akter who was mercilessly tortured yet she was not allowed to leave the job and return to her own country. Instead of her

Writ seeks probe into allegation against SP Harun

Court Correspondent :A writ petition was filed with the High Court on Tuesday seeking its directive to probe into the allegations of corruption and abuse of power against former Narayanganj

President's rule in Maharashtra

PTI,  New Delhi/Mumbai :President's rule was imposed in Maharashtra on Tuesday evening amid a political impasse, after Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari in a report to the Centre stated that formation

Fatal train crash in Kasba

Fatal train crash in Kasba

Staff Reporter :At least 16 passengers were killed and more than 100 others injured as Dhaka-bound Intercity Train Turna Nishita Express crashed into Chattogram-bound Udayan Express from Sylhet at Mondobhag

Canada backs probe into Rohingya genocide

Anadolu Agency, Trenton, Canada :Canada on Monday lauded Gambia's bid to bring Myanmar to court to answer genocide charges against its Rohingya minority."Canada welcomes Gambia's submission to the International Court

Crops worth Tk 2.63b destoryed by cyclone

Staff Reporter :Crops worth Tk 2.63 billion have been damaged by cyclone Bulbul made landfall in the country on Saturday, says Minister for Agriculture Muhammad Abdur Razzaque."The losses were incurred

Councillor Monju sent to jail

A Dhaka court on Tuesday sent Dhaka South City Corporation (DSCC) councillor Moynul Haque Monju to jail after end of his 10-day remand in two cases filed for possessing illegal

Shiv Sena ready to form govt in Maharashtra

NDTV, New Delhi :The Shiv Sena's plans to take power in Maharashtra after ending its alliance with long-term partner BJP are on hold with the Congress holding the key. Sharad

HC forms judicial body to probe into negligence to prevent dengue

Staff Reporter :The High Court on Tuesday formed a two-member judicial committee to probe into the reasons for failure of the concerned authorities to take appropriate measures for the eradication

Miscreants loot 20kg gold from Benapole Customs godown

Benapole Correspondent :A group of miscreants have looted 20 kg gold from Benapole Customs House godown after breaking its confidential vault on Monday. However, Customs authorities confirmed that dollar and