Saturday, January 25, 2020 | ePaper

How to Talk to Children about Climate Change

Curb the Naive Governmental Interventions

  • Print


James L. Payne :
We smile at seeing those young faces waving placards out in the rain, urging action on the problem of climate change. But our smile is tinged with frustration, with the feeling that the youngsters live in another dimension and that we don't know how to reach them intellectually.
How They See It
The natural impulse is to want to explain how crushingly complicated this issue is. First, we point out, there is the uncertainty about the connection between human-released CO2 and storms, floods and fires, and all the other bad things that might happen. Then we want to explain that cutting down on CO2 is not easy, that everyone will have to make great sacrifices.
One has to weigh the different possible benefits that might come from stopping (or slowing) global warming against the costs of trying to counter it. This cost-benefit analysis involves a bundle of economic and moral questions. (For a good overview of the complexities of the climate change issue, read former NASA scientist Roy W. Spencer's 2008 book Climate Confusion.) For example, would saving butterfly X from extinction (assuming we could guarantee it) counterbalance the harm done to the working poor by taking $1,000 a year from each of them in a carbon tax? And so on.
However, I think this impulse to debate the complexities of the issue is misguided. The activists do not base their position on reasoning and calculations. The Climate Kids don't come to their demonstrations pushing wheelbarrows full of cost-benefit analyses. Most of them don't even know what cost-benefit analysis is. More importantly, they don't think they need to know about it.
Once it decides to act, they believe, government has all the expertise needed to make the correct calculations and the ability to craft policies that solve the problem without significantly hurting anybody-well, anybody except the very rich.
This is because, in their way of looking at the world, it is not their responsibility to fix society's problems. That task belongs to a higher power, to government. Their mission is simply to beseech this higher power to act. Once it decides to act, they believe, government has all the expertise needed to make the correct calculations and the ability to craft policies that solve the problem without significantly hurting anybody-well, anybody except the very rich.
We should not be all that surprised by their deep, instinctive trust of government. It is a social predisposition, one that affects all of us to some degree. The belief in government's wisdom and power is imparted to children very early in life as an article of faith, like the belief in Santa Claus. As children grow up, they begin to notice that government has flaws and that political leaders are not as wise as originally supposed. As a result, their faith in government declines somewhat, so that by age 30, as traditional wisdom has it, most people grow somewhat skeptical about government's ability to cure the world's problems.
But not everyone, and especially not today's climate activists. Faced with a staggeringly complex cost-benefit analysis that has most of us (older) folks scratching our heads, they are brimming with certainty that catastrophe is coming, and government can fix whatever is wrong.
We were given a telling illustration of this simplistic faith earlier this year when 29-year-old US Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez presented her "Green New Deal" proposal. This House resolution mentions dozens of dangers and problems that she believes to be connected with climate change, from mass migrations, wildfires, and the loss of coral reefs to declining life expectancy, wage stagnation, and the racial wealth divide.
How are these all problems to be solved? Ms. Ocasio-Cortez does not propose any specific law or regulation. She does not advocate, let's say, a 16 percent carbon tax and assure us that, according to her calculations, this measure will save 61 percent of the coral reefs, and prevent 53 percent of wildfires while reducing the income of the poor by only 8.2 percent. Like the schoolchildren demonstrating in the street, she leaves the task of figuring out the specific answers to a higher power. Indeed, her resolution begins with this appeal to the higher power: "It is the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal." Thus runs the thoughtless faith in government, a faith so deep that even an activist who literally is the government herself looks to "government" to solve problems she can't begin to analyze.
We need to urge our young idealists to remember that government is not a god with magical powers to fix any problem we notice but an imperfect agency composed of fallible human beings.
If in coming years we hope to curb the naive governmental interventions that bring so much ruin to the world, we need to address this belief in the efficacy of government. We need to urge our young idealists to remember that government is not a god with magical powers to fix any problem we notice but an imperfect agency composed of fallible human beings. One way to begin this conversation is to pose this question: "Given what you know about the people who have been in charge of government, is it reasonable to expect, in the future, a high level of rationality and responsibility from government?"

(Dr. James L. Payne is a research fellow at the Independent Institute and author. He earned his PhD in political science from the University of California at Berkeley, and he has taught political science at a number of universities including Yale University).

More News For this Category

Brain's ‘Hardware’ and ‘Software’

Brain's ‘Hardware’ and ‘Software’

William Klemm, PhD :Learning programs the brain. It is nature's way to create simultaneously both "hardware" and "software" for the brain. Neuroscientists have long known that learning experiences change

Child's well-being

Child's well-being

 Matheis, PhD :"I can't control my child!" :I hear this often by parents who are frustrated with their child's behaviors, their difficulty in not being able to make

Development of speaking skills

Development of speaking skills

Burieva Raykhon Xayrullaevna :Annotation: Communicative teaching is perhaps the most popular approach to foreign language. It usually prioritizes fluency over accuracy and it is therefore vital to obtain and

Students should bring out from stress cycle

Antar Sarkar :From the very beginning of student life, studying appears to be a stressful task for students. Guardians and social exertion push students into a cycle of stress

Teaching youth to cope with the situation

Teaching youth to cope with the situation

Alec L Miller, PsyD :Today's youth continue to be barraged by horrific images of death and violence that are happening in the most ordinary places.  Our 21st century youth

Educators must bridge the culture gap

Educators must bridge the culture gap

Sharon L. Nichols :America's teachers do not reflect the broad diversity of the students they serve. Consider the following. There are approximately 50 million students attending public elementary and

IUB Ascension 2019

IUB Ascension 2019

Jannatun Nur Sadiyat :It was back in 2016 when Independent University, Bangladesh Debate Club (IUBDC) was given the responsibility to organize a competition for school students. IUB Management wished

Philosophy of Begum Rokeya

Philosophy of Begum Rokeya

Md. Habibur Rahman :Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain (1880-1932) was a remarkable and luminous icon in Bangla literature for her leading role in women's education, progressive thinking and torchbearer of

BUP Photography Exhibition ends

BUP Photography Exhibition ends

Campus Report :BUP Photography Society (BUPPS) of Bangladesh University of Professionals (BUP) unveiled its flagship event Contrast 3.0 from 19 to 22 this month at Bangladesh Shilpakala Academy. BUP

Int'l confce on innovation at DU

Int'l confce on innovation at DU

Campus Report :A 2-day 2nd international conference on "Innovation in Engineering and Technology (ICIET)" began on Monday at Nabab Nawab Ali Chowdhury Senate Bhaban auditorium of Dhaka University (DU).