Sunday, October 20, 2019 | ePaper

Why your brain makes inconsistent choices

The brain areas that usually make rational choices sometimes make irrational ones too. This contradicts previous theories that have suggested rational and irrational decision-making are influenced by activity in separate parts of the brain, or by different thinking processes.

  • Print


Weekend Plus Desk :
conomists have noticed that people can behave inconsistently when making choices. According to economic theory, people should choose the same things every time, under the same circumstances because they are recognised as holding the same value as before. But people don't always do that. Sometimes consumers will switch their preferences, known in industry terms as ‘customer churn.’
While economists have previously called that as an error in rationality, a new Canadian study found that an important part of inconsistent choice-making is due to idiosyncratic activity in the brain areas that assess value.
“If the value of a Coke is higher to you than a Pepsi, then you should choose the Coke every single time,” explained study’s co-author Ryan Webb, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management. “But because of these ‘noisy’ fluctuations in neural activity, so often, the Pepsi is better than the Coke.”
Prof Webb, Vered Kurtz-David, Prof Dotan Persitz, and Prof Dino Levy from Tel Aviv University were able to observe the phenomenon by getting research volunteers to play a series of lotteries while lying inside a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scanner. The fMRI monitors neural activity by detecting changes in blood flow to different parts of the brain.
The volunteers had to choose between different combinations of tokens directed towards two simultaneous lotteries, each with a 50 per cent chance of being the winner. Each volunteer played the lotteries multiple times in quick succession while inside the fMRI.
The studies showed that the areas of the brain that were most active during the most inconsistent choices were the same areas responsible for evaluating value. In other words, the brain areas that usually make rational choices sometimes make irrational ones too, suggested the study published in Nature Communications. This contradicts previous theories that have suggested rational and irrational decision-making are influenced by activity in separate parts of the brain, or by different thinking processes, an idea popularised in Daniel Kahneman's book, Thinking Fast and Slow.
The results suggest that occasional inconsistent choices are fundamental to how a typical brain works, regardless of efforts to ensure people stick religiously to their usual preferences.
Previously, a 2004-study suggested how brain battles itself over short-term rewards and long-term goals and what could be the implications right from economic theory to addiction research. The US study involved researchers at four universities who through brain imaging of 14 Princeton University student participants, studied how they made choices between small but immediate rewards or larger awards that they would receive later.
‘For example, people who are offered the choice of $10 today or $11 tomorrow are likely to choose to receive the lesser amount immediately. But if given a choice between $10 in one year or $11 in a year and a day, people often choose the higher, delayed amount,’ the study mentioned.
The study grew out of the then emerging discipline of neuroeconomics, which investigated the mental and neural processes that drive economic decision-making.
It showed that decisions involving the possibility of immediate reward activated parts of the brain influenced heavily by neural systems associated with emotion.
In contrast, all the decisions the students made - whether short- or long-term - activated brain systems that are associated with abstract reasoning.
In classic economic theory, such a choice is irrational because people are inconsistent in their treatment of the day-long time delay. While some argue that the brain has a single decision-making process with a built-in inconsistency, and others argued that the pattern results from the competing influence of two brain systems.

More News For this Category

These yoga poses are excellent for gut

These yoga poses are excellent for gut

Weekend Plus Desk :When we talk about weight loss, gut health is a topic that cannot be avoided. A healthy gut is not only necessary for your immune system,

Blueberry Parfait

Blueberry Parfait

Blueberry Parfait is a no-bake and no-cook dessert recipe that you can prepare for your loved ones on occasions like kitty party, game night, and pot luck. This parfait

Simple hacks to beautify  bedroom space

Simple hacks to beautify bedroom space

Weekend Plus Desk :Abedroom is a home in itself. The vibe of a bedroom can immensely influence your everyday life, from the way you sleep to your energy flow

My Birth Day

-M Mizanur RahmanThe movement of this life is strange.That none can discern its range.We are living ever in wonder agewhere time and tide care no stage.I am landing on

Poet Kamini Roy

Poet Kamini Roy

Anirudha Kahaly :Kamini Roy, (1864-1933) Poet and social worker, was born on 12 October 1864 in the village of Basanda in then Bakerganj district. Her father, Chandicharan Sen, was

Nizami Ganjavi: Poet for all humanity

Nizami Ganjavi: Poet for all humanity

Teymur Kerimli :zerbaijan’s literature is a unique spiritual treasure-house for its people and there is no doubt that Nizami Ganjavi is one of the greatest representatives of this literary

Common myths about teeth-whitening busted

Common myths about teeth-whitening busted

Dr Meghna Dang :Asparkling white smile not only helps to enhance confidence and self-esteem but also improves one’s appearance dramatically. As a result, teeth-whitening treatments are among the most

Dry-brushing for healthy glowing skin

Dry-brushing for healthy glowing skin

Weekend Plus Desk :Nope, a brisk brush is not only for our furry pets. Dry brushing your skin removes all the dead skin cells off the body and enhances

Basic weight lifting moves for a beginner

Basic weight lifting moves for a beginner

Weekend Plus Desk :Weight lifting workout, in the beginning, can be quite intimidating. The confusion about which weight to use for which form of exercise is natural. Beginners are

Stop child from lying

Stop child from lying

Md Altaf Hussain :Lying is a skill all children learn. It is a tool for avoiding blame or punishment, and for shoring up a poor self-image. Most children tell