Monday, June 17, 2019 | ePaper

The 'Unpeople' Of India!

British Taught Rulers The Art Of "Divide And Rule"

  • Print
Abdul Khaliq :
I fear for our future as a secular, multicultural country that once celebrated a richness of culture and tradition. Till not long ago we affirmed our common humanity even as we celebrated our differences. Our nation represented diversity, kindness, compassion and a revulsion of extremist views. But, over time, our collective souls have been deadened by violence, deepening communal and caste divides and the most perverse thinking. The cosmopolitan spirit has been throttled by hyper nationalism, populism and a deep distrust of the liberal values of tolerance and inclusion. A creeping majoritarianism is spreading across the land.
In this overheated, protracted election season, Muslims are up against it, caught between a rock and a hard place. Theirs is an Orwellian world where they are the "unpeople"- a term coined by George Orwell in his scary masterpiece 1984, to define those whose names and existence had been erased because they had incurred "Big Brother's" ire. Muslims now have to live with the bleak truth that the most powerful political party and its ideological parent, with tentacles spread across the country, are pathologically hostile to Muslims. What makes their plight infinitely worse is the fact that even the major allegedly secular party has consigned Muslims to social invisibility. Can one trust a party that is afraid to even allude to the Muslims' problems, let alone address them?
When the PM evoked the 1984 mass slaughter of Sikhs and quoted Rajiv Gandhi's infamous justification about the inevitable effect of the falling of a big tree, why did the Congress president not hit back by recalling the 2002 Gujarat riots and Modi's Newtonian observation justifying the killing of hundreds of Muslims as a reaction to an action? He refrained, not for any ethical reason, but simply for fear of being seen as empathetic to Muslims and their problems and of equating the two tragedies. Caught between the flagrant hostility of the right-wing and the fraudulent concern of the secular front, Muslims are India's outcasts.
In today's India, where all issues across the political spectrum are seen through the lens of identity politics, Muslims are vilified for their custom, dress and tradition. They are physically attacked for the food they eat, discriminated against in employment, housing, and even civic amenities, and, they are routinely victimised by law-enforcement authorities simply for being Muslim. Social media is awash with the most hateful, stereotypical portrayal of Muslims as terrorist sympathisers, baby producing factories and worse. Although India has been the home of Islam and its adherents for much more than a millennium, Muslims today are constantly pilloried about their loyalty to the nation.
All assessments about Muslims are universalised, in black and white and deeply problematic. In a conversation with two CRPF sub-inspectors who have recently returned from Kashmir (I did not reveal that I was Muslim), I was told that "these Muslims are a nuisance as even their women throw stones at us." Please note that the stone-throwing by the disgruntled Kashmiris is perceived as a common trait of Muslims - all 190 million of them. Their other complaints were that Muslims support Pakistan and insist on eating only halal meat. When I asked how the civil unrest in Kashmir could be resolved, I got an answer that stunned me: "Make sure that the police force in Kashmir is recruited only from the Shia community and they will teach these Sunnis a lesson!" How well have the British taught us the art of "divide and rule" and of polarising communities! The conversation filled me with anguish at the gratuitous distrust and hatred for Muslims. The animosity runs deep and is expressed by ordinary citizens in a matter-of-fact tone that is unnerving.
I recall clearly the sense of cautious optimism among Muslims when Narendra Modi assumed power in 2014. His swearing-in was a strikingly symbolic moment, epitomised by the presence of the Pakistani PM that signalled hope of rapprochement with Pakistan (Indian Muslims know through experience that their well-being is linked to this crucial relationship). The PM represented a more decisive polity that promised an equitable social order expressed most eloquently in the Socratic slogan, "Sabka saath sabka vikas". This slogan encapsulated this nation's foremost mission of fostering social solidarity based on the principle that every human being matters. Minorities felt reassured by the PM's emphatic assertion in 2015 that "my government will not allow any religious group, belonging to the majority or minority, to incite hatred against others, overtly or covertly." He repeatedly made appeals to preserve our core values of diversity, tolerance and plurality, calling on Hindus and Muslims to work together to fight poverty instead of fighting one another. His stunning embrace of Nawaz Sharif on Christmas Day 2015 filled everyone with hope.
On the ground, however, India began witnessing a deepening cultural mutation as vigilante squads terrorised and lynched Muslims in the name of protecting the cow, launched "ghar wapsi" campaigns that have all but ended the freedom to choose one's faith and used "love jihad" to stifle any kind of solidarity between the two communities. Minorities began to believe that the present dispensation's aim is to convert India into the Hindu Rashtra of Hindutva where Muslims and Christians would live as second-class citizens. The current election rhetoric has only exacerbated those fears. The BJP Lok Sabha candidate for Barabanki boasted that "Narendra Modi has made attempts to break the morale of Muslims. Vote for Modi if you want to destroy the breed of Muslims."
We are on the cusp of having a new government at the Centre. Opinion polls and the most reliable - the bookies - predict victory for the NDA, but with a reduced majority. Ironically, the return of Modi as PM is the best hope for peace within the country and the neighbourhood. Imran Khan was right when he said that only Modi could help resolve Kashmir. He is the only leader with the power to rein in the lunatics whose purpose in life is to polarise communities and engage in eternal war with Pakistan. In any case, the new government's first task would be to combat the overpowering atmosphere of distrust and hate bedevilling society which constitutes the foremost threat to the nation, more so than terrorism. The creation of a truly secular society free of prejudice and discrimination must be the prime mission.

(Abdul Khaliq, a former civil servant, secretary general of the Lok Janshakti Party, writes for Indian Express)

More News For this Category

Global community must come forward to save South Sudan

SOME seven million people in South Sudan would face acute food shortages, while more than 20,000 are close to famine, the World Food Programme warned on Friday. The warning, which

Border killings not acceptable by any means

INDIA'S Border Security Force's new Director General Rajni Kant Mishra called the killings along the Bangladesh-India border as 'unfortunate deaths'. "They were killed during skirmishes between miscreants and the BSF

Hong Kong Extradition Row

Ana Nicolaci da Costa :Changes to Hong Kong's extradition law could hurt the autonomy that has made it one of Asia's main financial hubs.The government is seeking to allow extraditions

Sustainable Fashion

Lisa Greenlee :The Copenhagen Fashion Summit celebrated its tenth anniversary last week. The summit, which is often referred to as the Davos of fashion, is a key date in the

Budget should be more ‘realistic’

LEADING think-tank Centre for Policy Dialogue in a post-budget discussion said the FY2019-20 budget will favour affluent section of the society instead of establishing equity and social justice, resulting in

Don't let successes go in vain

A total of 298 people were killed and 860 sustained injuries in road accidents across the country during the Eid-ul Fitr vacation. A report of Bangladesh Jatri Kallyan Samiti presented

Can Iran Pressure US?

Dr. John C. Hulsman :Confusion surrounds the attack on the two tankers in the Gulf of Oman on Thursday, with the stricken ships ablaze just south of the Strait of

Safety-Net Programmes

Dr. Forqan Uddin Ahmed :Bangladesh is a developing country, where poverty and inequality among the households are common. This is not only in this country. Other developing countries also suffer

Readers’ Forum

Social Media is Increasing Mobile Phone AddictionMobile phone in this era is the most necessary thing in the world. We can't think of going a single day without it. Of

Create enough jobs to stop risky migration of youths

NEWS media reported that about 64 undocumented Bangladeshi migrants who have been stuck in a boat off Tunisia for at least 14 days are refusing to come ashore in