Thursday, June 27, 2019 | ePaper

Suppressing discussion never solves the problem

The mosque attacks are latest incidents weaponized by politicians

  • Print
Thomas L. Knapp :
Everywhere one looks these days, the world seems to be moving away from debate on contentious subjects and toward demands that those who have unpopular opinions-or even just ask impertinent questions-be forcibly silenced.
 "You will never hear me mention his name,"  Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said of Brenton Tarrant, the sole suspect in two deadly attacks on mosques in Christchurch. "He may have sought notoriety but here in New Zealand we will give him nothing-not even his name."
That's fine as a personal decision, I guess, but not as a top-down decision for her fellow New Zealanders. Even as Ardern spoke, police working for her government were arresting at least two people for sharing the shooter's live-streamed video of the attacks on social media.
Across the Tasman Sea, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison is calling on the governments of G20 countries to implement measures "including appropriate filtering, detecting and removing of content by actors who encourage, normalise, recruit, facilitate or commit terrorist and violent atrocities."
Let's be clear about what Morrison, other "world leaders," and significant segments of activist communities and even the general public, are demanding (and to a frightful degree already implementing): Internet censorship.
This isn't really a new development. The mosque attacks are merely the latest incident weaponized by politicians and activists in service to a long-running campaign against public discussion and debate that requires them to make arguments and persuade instead of just bark orders and compel.
The fictional "memory hole" of the IngSoc regime in George Orwell's 1984 stood for more than half a century as an oft-cited and wisely acknowledged warning. Now that hole is opening up beneath us for real and threatening to suck us down into a new Dark Age of "thought crime" and "unpersons."
The threat is content-independent. Renaming climate change skeptics "deniers" and demanding "investigations" of them, or pressuring media to ban discussions of policy on vaccines, is just as evil as suing Alex Jones for promulgating bizarre theories about the Sandy Hook massacre.  
The only appropriate response to "bad" speech-that is, speech one disagrees with-is "better" speech.
Attempting to shut down your opponents' ability to participate in an argument isn't itself a winning argument. Forbidding your opponents to speak to a problem doesn't solve that problem.  In fact, those tactics are tantamount to admitting that your arguments are less persuasive and that your solutions can't withstand scrutiny.
Freedom of thought and expression are primary, foundational rights. They make it possible for us to hash out issues and solve problems peaceably instead of by force. Any attempt to suppress them is itself a call for totalitarianism and the alternative to those liberties is social and political death.

(Thomas L. Knapp writes from Florida)

More News For this Category

Make workplaces safe for the women

THE survey — that found 43 per cent female garment workers face sexual harassment and 90 per cent victims of mental torture in the workplace, public transport and rented house

Keep liver transplant affordable

IN the latest development, surgeons at Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University have successfully performed liver transplant at a government hospital for the first time. Media on Tuesday reported that, a

Public Relations

Md. Arafat Rahman :Public Relations (PR) - the term has been heard for several years in the career world and the young generation of today has become very interested in

Big Challenge

Dr. Md. Shairul Mashreque :Mustafa Kamal has become Finance Minister replacing MA Muhith.  Muhit was an experienced Finance Minister — preparing and reading budget at the Parliament for a decade.

No effective strategy to make transport sector disciplined

DESPITE the nationwide road safety movement, more than 4.58 lakh unfit vehicles are on the roads and 1.68 lakh of them operate alone in the capital city. Since unfit vehicles

Food adulteration business must stop

RESEARCHERS at Dhaka University on Tuesday said all the samples of milk products; edible oils and spices they tested were substandard. According to newspaper reports, they have found traces of

Facebook's Libra

Thomas L. Knapp :In mid-June, Facebook -- in cahoots with 28 partners in the financial and tech sectors -- announced plans to introduce Libra, a blockchain-based virtual currency.The world's governments

Education or Nuisance

Sir Frank Peters :Why are children's heavy schoolbooks not produced in two equal parts with Part 2 only carried to school after the completion of Part 1?It's a well-known truism

Corruption isn't a crime at all for them!

THERE is no visible decline in corruption by government officials and employees despite significant increases in their salaries and other benefits over the years, the Transparency International Bangladesh has found

Train accident: Responsible persons must be punished

AT least five people, including three women, were killed and more than 100 injured as the Upaban Express -- a passenger train heading to the capital from Sylhet -- derailed