Tuesday, March 19, 2019 | ePaper

The best type of exercise to burn fat

According to a new review, super-short intervals could even, in some cases, burn more fat than a long walk or jog, but the effort involved needs to be arduous

  • Print


Gretchen Reynolds :
A few minutes of brief, intense exercise may be as effective as much lengthier walks or other moderate workouts for incinerating body fat, according to a helpful new review of the effects of exercise on fat loss. The review finds that super-short intervals could even, in some cases, burn more fat than a long walk or jog, but the effort involved needs to be arduous.
I have written many times about the health, fitness and brevity benefits of high-intensity interval training, which typically involves a few minutes - or even seconds - of strenuous exertion followed by a period of rest, with the sequence repeated multiple times. Most workouts require less than half an hour, from beginning to end (including a warm-up and cool-down), and the strenuous portions of the workout are even briefer.
But despite this concision, studies show that interval workouts can improve aerobic fitness, blood sugar control, blood pressure and other measures of health and fitness to the same or a greater extent than standard endurance training, such as brisk walking or jogging, even if it lasts two or three times as long.
People being people, though, the most common question I hear about quickie intervals and have asked, on my own behalf, is whether they also will aid in weight control and fat loss.
Only a few past studies have directly compared the fat-burning effects of endurance training to those of short interval workouts, however, and their results have been inconsistent. Some indicate that intervals prompt significant fat loss and others that any losses are negligible when compared to the effects of endurance training.
But those studies have almost all been small and short-term. They also used many different approaches to interval and endurance exercise, making the findings difficult to interpret.
So, for the new review, which was published in January in The British Journal of Sports Medicine, researchers from Brazil and Britain decided to pull together as much data as possible from all of the existing, high-quality studies looking at intervals and body fat.
Scrolling through medical library databases, they eventually found 36 studies that involved randomized experiments - not surveys or other epidemiological data - comparing the effects of endurance training to those from interval workouts.
The experiments had to have lasted at least a month and included body-composition measurements at the start and finish, even if changes to body fat had not been the primary focus of the study. (And in most of these experiments, they were not.)
Then the researchers pooled numbers from the studies, giving them a total of more than 1,000 participants, young and old, male and female.
The moderate-exercise routines used in the studies varied considerably, with some involving walking and others jogging, cycling or swimming. In general, the endurance-style workouts lasted for about 40 minutes.
The interval sessions likewise differed from one study to the next, but most involved intervals lasting for a few minutes at a time, at a pace just below all-out effort, which is typical of HIIT.
Others required a few seconds of absolutely all-out exertion, an approach the researchers’ dubbed sprint-interval training, or SIT. Then the researchers simply compared fat loss after the different exercise programs.
The results should be encouraging for anyone who exercises. Both moderate training and intervals, of all types, led to reductions in body fat, the researchers found. These reductions were absolute, meaning that people shed some of their actual fat mass, and also relative, meaning that they lowered the percentage of their body mass that was fat.
The changes also for the most part occurred whether or not people lost a noticeable amount of overall weight, suggesting that they might be losing fat while gaining muscle.
Perhaps most important for people drawn to quickie exercise, interval training, especially SIT workouts, often burned more fat, in absolute terms, than prolonged, moderate exercise, with interval trainers dropping an average of about 3.5 pounds of fat during most studies, versus about 2.5 pounds for moderate exercisers.
It is worth noting that this is a one-pound difference, which in real-world terms is almost negligible.
In fact, the primary takeaway of the review could be that, “due to the similarity of outcomes, there can be flexibility in choice of exercise approach,” for anyone hoping to trim fat, says James Steele, an associate professor of sport and exercise science at Solent University in Southampton, England, who conducted the review with colleagues from the Federal University of Goiás in Brazil and other institutions.
Plan your workouts around your preferences and schedules, he says, and not concerns about which type of exercise might better trim fat.
Of course, even with 1,000 participants, the review remains relatively small. In addition, interpreting the data from individual volunteers can be somewhat baffling. In every study and every exercise program, some people lost more fat than others and some much less, for reasons that remain unclear.
“If you prefer longer yet easier-effort exercise, then go for it,” he says. “If you want to pump it up in an HIIT session, be my guest.”

More News For this Category

Bhutan in off-season

Bhutan in off-season

Akhil Sharma :here is only one traffic light in Bhutan. It is at the top of the main road in Thimphu, the country's capital. A policeman in a tight

From Aloo Parantha to Japanese Sticky Rice: Easy gluten-free recipes

From Aloo Parantha to Japanese Sticky Rice: Easy gluten-free recipes

Ingredients :Gluten-free chapati flour - 1 cup+1/3 cupWater to help you knead the doughSalt to tasteOnion - 1/2 super finely chopped.Green chillies - 2-3 finely (chopped)Green coriander - 10

Let others also live

Let others also live

Weekend Plus Desk :Onnojibon, a book based on articles, written by prominent Journalist Jamaluddin Jamal, was published recently by Nayaprobaho Prokashoni. In this book the author reflected the plights

Blood holds key to liver regeneration

Blood holds key to liver regeneration

Weekend Plus Desk :he liver is the only organ in the body that can regenerate. A recent study shows that the blood-clotting protein fibrinogen may hold the key as

Great leader

Great leader

    -Mohammad Mamun Mia Breaking the shackles of subjection We earned our emancipation The Bengali nation has not bowed down to the usurper Has no question to surrender Due

Sufi Literature Wakil Ahmed

ufi Literature, a distinctive stream of medieval Bangla literature, was inspired by Sufism. Sufi saints started coming to Bangladesh from Arabia and Iran in the mid-eleventh century. After Bakhtiyar

 Jules Verne: Life and writings

Jules Verne: Life and writings

Literature Desk :ules Verne (1828-1905) is frequently called the ‘father of science fiction.’ Among all writers, only Agatha Christie’s works have been translated more. Verne wrote numerous plays, essays,

Exposure to secondhand smoke can increase risk of kidney disease

Exposure to secondhand smoke can increase risk of kidney disease

Weekend Plus Desk :he perils of passive smoking need no retelling. However, according to a report quoted in The New York Times, being exposed to secondhand smoke can also

Ways to rebuild a relationship

Ways to rebuild a relationship

Weekend Plus Desk :ay be, we all know how a relationship crumbles when one partner breaks the trust of the other because trust is that solid rock upon which

Can you tell if your  child is lying?

Can you tell if your child is lying?

Weekend Plus Desk :hildren start lying as early as two years old and they’re really good at it, developmental researcher Kang Lee tells us in this Ted Talk. Having