Thursday, June 20, 2019 | ePaper

You’re turning into your parents

There's a limit to how much insight can be gleaned from various one-dimensional scales of personality traits - extroversion, for example, or neuroticism. There's so much more richness in watching the way our parents and other relatives undermine their own happiness, or find it against the odds. They are not me, but they do share a good portion of DNA

  • Print


Weekend Plus Desk :
ith so many family gatherings this time of year, many of us notice that our siblings are turning into our parents, and some of our partners’ and friends’ kids are turning into their parents. That’s no illusion. As scientists have learned from ‘nature versus nurture’ studies on twins and adoptees, humans become more like our biological parents and other family members as we get older.
This is a little scary. It’s not that we don’t love the anxious relative who can’t enjoy a holiday dinner because her stuffing wasn’t perfect, or the impulsive one who can't stop at three glasses of eggnog even though he will regret it. It’s just unnerving to realize they are reflections of the selves we might become.
I learned about escalating family resemblances from talking with Robert Plomin, a behavioural geneticist at the King’s College London. He describes the phenomenon in his recent book, Blueprint: How DNA Makes Us Who We Are. At first, I thought the interview might be contentious, considering that I’d recently written a column titled You Are Not Your DNA.
It turned out we disagreed very little. He and I shared a fascination with families. His pioneering studies used families - following adopted kids as well as their birth mothers.
He found that kids take after their birth mothers, but not their adoptive parents, in cognitive skills, interests and personality traits. And as they get older, the resemblance only got stronger.
He attributes this to the fact that people with literary, musical, mathematical or scientific inclinations will construct environments that amplify these predispositions; they are not necessarily or primarily products of those environments. He even found adoptees resembled their birth mothers in such seemingly non-genetic traits as television watching and likelihood of getting divorced. But then, these are influenced by personality traits. (Not that the traits associated with divorce are necessarily bad. As my dad used to say, better a vacancy than a bad tenant - and as I've gotten older, I’ve come to agree more.)
The adoptive parents had surprisingly little influence on anything measurable. “Parents don’t have the levers to pull they think they do,” he said. Despite all the hype about tiger moms, teaching grit and 10,000 hours of practice, he said, the reality is that kids are not blobs of clay you can mould.
This does not mean that we're shaped only by nature. It's just that people have misunderstood nurture. To Plomin, nurture is not how you were parented but the multitude of slings and arrows you encounter in your life. As he put it in is book, “What makes us different environmentally are random experiences, not systematic forces like families.” We are moulded by unpredictable forces, but the very nature of the clay is a mix of our ancestors.
Some reviewers have accused Plomin of being a genetic determinist - that is, putting too much emphasis on genes as the drivers of our futures. In the introduction to the book, he does indeed say that genetic testing could provide a sort of crystal ball.
But in our conversation, he said genetic tests (and family members) show us a future that might be - not a future that must be. You might have a high risk of becoming an alcoholic, and knowing that might make you more conscious about avoiding this outcome. He said he had a high risk of becoming overweight, and that he is indeed somewhat overweight and has fought the battle of the bulge for years. But he doesn’t think that means he can’t achieve a healthy weight.
Plomin has also studied twins and the similarities between monozygotic, or ‘identical,’ twins. They share almost identical DNA and usually look quite similar, but of course they are unique individuals. That was strikingly illustrated in the recently released documentary Three Identical Strangers, about monozygotic triplets separated in infancy and reunited at 19. The three young men looked alike, had the same smile and the same gestures, but (spoiler alert) one was much more troubled than the other two and eventually committed suicide.
The filmmakers try to suggest that the adoptive father is to blame, though there was no convincing evidence that he did anything wrong. Reading Plomin's book made me appreciate how brutally unfair this accusation may have been, and how dismissive of the influence of random slings and arrows.
Plomin is a great enthusiast for the newest generation of genetic tests, now capable of giving us information on traits that are influenced by a multitude of genes, including cognitive skills and personality traits.
That might be considered an advance, as long as this information isn’t used against us - but there's no guarantee it wouldn’t be used badly and stupidly by employers, teachers or people trying to sell us stuff we don't need.
Even if I could get such results confidentially, there's a limit to how much insight can be gleaned from various one-dimensional scales of personality traits - extroversion, for example, or neuroticism. There’s so much more richness in watching the way our parents and other relatives undermine their own happiness, or find it against the odds. They are not me, but they do share a good portion of DNA. We navigate around many of the same rocky shoals, but I imagine that if I'm careful, I can avoid running into them. Some of them.
But this might just be a personal preference for stories. I turn to science when I want to understand the natural world and trends in human behaviour. For wisdom on how to live, I find myself increasingly gravitating toward novels, stories and people. My mom was the same way.

More News For this Category

A walk through Kolkata’s colonial past

A walk through Kolkata’s colonial past

Panchali Dey :olonial history is in the DNA of Kolkata, and there is no denying the fact. In fact, a memorial is also dedicated to the British queen, the

Refreshing summer coolers to keep hydrated in the scorching heat

Refreshing summer coolers to keep hydrated in the scorching heat

Weekend Plus Desk :ummer is at its peak with the temperature rising to over 45 degrees, making it difficult to step outside. At such a time, it becomes extremely

New method may help predict depression in new mothers

New method may help predict depression in new mothers

Weekend Plus Desk :onitoring a woman’s relationship with her body during pregnancy may help predict how a new mother will bond with her unborn baby and whether she will

Why are there so many sufferings?

Why are there so many sufferings?

- Dr Sahjahan KabirWalking on the city streets the whole dayThe tired boy looked for little shelter,Little touch of affection and a small meal.But he got nothing, with deep

Aleksandr Pushkin

Vasily Tropinin :leksandr Sergeyevich Pushkin (June 6, 1799 - February 10, 1837) was a Russian romantic writer whom most Russians consider their greatest poet and the founder of modern

 Love to be felt, not learnt

Love to be felt, not learnt

Anis Fatema :he melody began in the most sophisticated period of century. The stars craved for a new era while the birds were about to sing the welcome note.

Naturalist writer Dwijen Sharma

Naturalist writer Dwijen Sharma

Literature Desk :wijen Sharma (29 May 1929-15 September 2017) was a Bangladeshi naturalist and science writer. He was awarded Bangla Academy Literary Award in 1987 and Ekushey Padak in

From controlling diabetes to  skin care:  The health  benefits of jamun

From controlling diabetes to skin care: The health benefits of jamun

Weekend Plus Desk :easonal fruits come packed with numerous health benefits, which is why it is often recommended to include them in our diets. While there are many summer

Morning Vs Evening workout debateWeekend Plus Desk

Morning Vs Evening workout debateWeekend Plus Desk

his is one question that continues to fuel the debate for fitness lovers. Is exercise better in the morning or night? Studies say timing matters if you want optimum

Just 16-minute sleep loss may put your job  at risk

Just 16-minute sleep loss may put your job at risk

Weekend Plus Desk :osing just 16 minutes of sleep could be the difference between a clear-headed day at the office or one filled with distractions, say scientists. A study,