Tuesday, March 26, 2019 | ePaper

Half of university tuition fees spent on teaching

  • Print


Sean Coughlan :
Less than half of the tuition fee paid by students in England can be spent on the cost of teaching, says research from a university think tank. The Higher Education Policy Institute says the rest is spent on buildings, IT and libraries, administration, or welfare such as mental health support.
It comes as a review is scrutinising the cost of student fees and loans. A separate public spending watchdog report warns that the sale of student loans is providing poor value.
The Public Accounts Committee says that student loans with a face value of £3.5bn were sold last year to private investors for £1.7bn - with MPs unconvinced this was a good deal for taxpayers.
The review of post-18 education funding, commissioned by the prime minister, is examining how to redesign university fees and student loans.
There have been suggestions that the review is looking at cutting fees to £6,500 - raising questions about the cost of delivering courses.
Both university reports from the Higher Education Policy Institute and the Public Accounts Committee examine whether students and taxpayers are getting value for money.
How is the tuition fee spent?
The think tank report says that universities might only spend 45% of tuition fee income on teaching - with the rest spent on other services or administration.
Students should be given much more information about how their fee is being used, says the study.
A breakdown from Nottingham Trent per student showed:
39% spent on academic staff, course equipment and staff-related costs
36% spent on buildings, libraries, IT, sports, careers, admissions, staff, administration and widening access to poorer applicants
17% invested in "enhancing teaching, research infrastructure and the student experience"
8% spent on professional services, including marketing, finance and the vice-chancellor's pay
The research also shows that universities can have very different levels of dependency on the current £9,250 annual tuition fees.
Tuition fees were only 15% of income for Cambridge, but at Falmouth it was 83% and Nottingham Trent was 81%.
This puts financial pressure on universities to recruit - and last week it was revealed that a university had to be bailed out with an emergency loan.
 "Tuition fees were introduced 20 years ago and they have been tripled twice. Ministers and regulators have repeatedly demanded information on where the fees go. Yet there is still little information available," says the institute's director, Nick Hillman.
The Office for Students said: "We can identify and will act when they are not transparent about value for money or are not delivering strong enough outcomes for students or taxpayers."
Who profits from selling the student loan book?
A report from the Public Accounts Committee warns that the taxpayer should be getting a better deal when the government sells off student loans to private investors.
Last year, it says the government only received a return of 48p in the pound - in the deal in which £3.5bn of student debt was sold for £1.7bn.
The MPs recognise that the full value will not be obtained, because so many students are unlikely to pay back all that they have borrowed.
"In this case, government received too little in return for what it gave up," says the committee.
The committee, which oversees government spending, says it is "not convinced" by explanations for the pricing of these public assets.
It also calls for more transparency about the investors profiting from the sale.
"The public deserves to know who stands to gain from the sale of public assets," says committee chair, Meg Hillier.
Labour's Angela Rayner described it as "ripping off the taxpayer".
But a spokeswoman for the Department for Education said: "We are confident that we achieved value for money for taxpayers from the first sale of student loans.
"As the National Audit Office has found, we received more for the loans than the value to government of retaining them, further strengthening the public finances."
But she said the system was designed on the basis that "many students will never fully pay back their loans".

(The writer is BBC correspondent).

More News For this Category

Protecting child rights and ensuring child safety

Protecting child rights and ensuring child safety

Md.  Shairul Mashreque and  M. Abul Kashem Mozumder :Contemporary concerns about human rights have now been focused on empowerment of the children as a vulnerable group. But empowerment of

How students learn by helping marginalised communities

How students learn by helping marginalised communities

Campus Desk :How can you help improve the eye health of people in your local community? Offering a cup of tea and a chat might not be the first

How to get in-and out of-politics

Sara Bliss :It's not uncommon to pivot into politics from a different career. Yet, one of the probabilities of being an elected official is that another career leap will most

Education—key to gender equality

Education—key to gender equality

Armida Salsiah Alisjahbana  :Equal rights have been demanded and promised for generations, but last year a shift occurred in the women's movement. Across Asia and the Pacific and around the

Business students can learn from the army

Business students can learn from the army

Alyssa Walker :Military personnel possess many positive qualities: problem-solving, overcoming adversity, resilience, a willingness to try, teamwork, collaboration, communication, and innovation. Sound familiar?It should, especially if you're a business student.Military-style

Digital transformation and robotics

Digital transformation and robotics

G. John Cole :Digital transformation, digital disruption, technology management, strategy, innovation, and technology are very hot topics that executives can't ignore anymore-whatever their field. Embracing the exciting world of

The easy way to learn a new language

The easy way to learn a new language

Peter Rubinstein and Bryan Lufkin :Learning a new language is an inherently scary idea. Thousands of unfamiliar words, an entirely different grammatical structure and the high potential for embarrassment

Breaking down walls not building them

Breaking down walls not building them

Sean Coughlan :"Let's put it this way, we're interested in breaking down walls and not building them," says Meric Gertler, president of the University of Toronto. The head of

How business students can prepare for Brexit

How business students can prepare for Brexit

G. John Cole :You have probably heard quite a bit about Brexit - the UK's departure from the European Union, which is due to happen on March 29th this

Boys vs girls' learning: Biological concerns

Boys vs girls' learning: Biological concerns

Mili Saha :Is that 'Brain' which makes differences?Corpus callosum is the neural cable connecting the two hemispheres in the brain, and it is much thicker in girls, which clarifies