Tuesday, December 11, 2018 | ePaper

Learning music promotes creativity

  • Print


Life DeskĀ  :
Music improvisers may be more creative than musicians who do not improvise. A pattern of electrical activity is found among improvisers but not among other musicians. Musical improvisation is the ability to compose music at the spur of the moment without prior practice.
Musicians who are able to distinguish between chords that can be used interchangeably in a piece of music are more creative than musicians who cannot improvise on the chords, new study finds.
The brains of musicians who are improvisers showed a pattern of electrical activity distinct from non-improvising musicians in the study conducted at the Columbia University.
'Musicians who learn to quickly substitute chords and are able to distinguish between chords that can be used interchangeably show a pattern of electrical activity distinct from non-improvising musicians.'
"It turns out that the degree to which we can predict how musicians respond to different types of musical substitution has nothing to do with how much they practice, but the way they practice," said the study's senior author, Paul Sajda, a biomedical engineer at Columbia Engineering and a member of Columbia's Data Science Institute. "Improvisational practice seems to reinforce how the brain represents different types of musical structures."
The researchers asked 40 musicians to listen to a series of chord progressions randomly interspersed with two types of chord variations: one from the same functional class (say, a similar chord with its notes inverted), and one from outside the class (say, a major chord juxtaposed against a minor chord).
The improvisers, most of them trained in jazz, identified the oddball chords unsuitable for substitution faster and more accurately than the mostly classically-trained musicians with limited improvisational practice. How well they performed, the study found, was largely predicted by their level of improvisation experience.
Improvisation is hardly confined to music - it underlies much of daily life. Faced with a delayed train, you might decide to walk or take the bus; a missing ingredient, the closest alternative. With a flexible mindset, a creative solution is often at hand. With music, as with cooking, the trick is knowing the rules of substitution, says the study's lead author, Andrew Goldman, a postdoctoral researcher at Columbian.
He explains: Having run out of lemons, an improvising chef will reach for a lime knowing that citrus fruit will work better in the recipe than, say, a banana, much as an improvising musician knows that a chord with a similar harmonic function will work better than one with a different function. In Goldman's experiments, the improvisers were quick to differentiate between the musical equivalent of easy-to-substitute limes and hard-to-substitute bananas.
In a 2015 study of varsity baseball players, Sajda, the biomedical engineer, found that experts categorized pitches in much the same way. The experts were better than non-ball players at making split-second calls distinguishing a fast ball from say, a curve ball, and deciding whether to swing. This insight became the basis for deCervo, a tech startup founded by two former students of Sajda's who are now using brain-training exercises to improve batting performance.
In a related study with Barnard College dance professor Colleen Thomas, Goldman compared how people with varying levels of training in dance, improvisational dance, and Contact Improvisation, a form of improvised dance with partners, responded as they watched Thomas perform everyday actions and dance moves.
In still unpublished results, researchers found that the dancers, despite not moving themselves, showed greater activity in the brain's motor cortex which controls movement. The effect was strongest in those with Contact Improvisation training.
Goldman was drawn to improvisation from his earliest piano lessons as a child growing up in southern California. "I would take the music I learned, transposing, changing the mode from major to minor, or mixing other musical elements together," he says. Later, as a composer and a concert pianist, Goldman's interest in the brain led him to the University of Cambridge for a Ph.D. in music cognition, and then to Columbia, where he just finished a three-year fellowship in the Presidential Scholars in Society and Neuroscience program.
When Goldman this spring put on Science! the Musical, a playful commentary about academic life that he wrote and performed in on piano, he was delighted when the lead singer embellished one song, "The Real World," with extra notes for emotional emphasis. "She had never done that in rehearsal, he says. "It worked very well."
This summer, Goldman heads to Western University in Ontario to continue studying the neuroscience of improvisation, a field that has expanded rapidly in recent years. Rather than focus on defining the subjective nature of improvisation, Goldman wants to go after questions with measurable answers. For example, how do different types of training influence musical perception? How do improvisers organize their knowledge of musical structures differently from non-improvisers?
George Lewis, a professor of composition and musicology at Columbia who co-edited the Oxford Handbook of Critical Improvisational Studies, says Goldman is off to a promising start.
"This work shows that far from being ineffable or mysterious, the practice of improvisation can be studied scientifically, yielding new knowledge about the brain and how we all get along in the world," said Lewis, who was not involved in the study. "This is important all by itself, and relevant to other work in cognitive psychology, neuroscience, and beyond."

Source-Eurekalert

More News For this Category

The mind is flat

The mind is flat

Nick Chater Ph.D. :We know characters in fiction as well as we know many, and perhaps most, of the people around us. Yet fictional characters are often sketched remarkably

Free eye camps in city, Raipur

Free eye camps in city, Raipur

Life Desk :Two free eye camps for the underprivileged people were held at New Castle International School premises in Jatrabari in the city and at Raipur Union Parishad Bhavan,

Women in agricultural sector

Women in agricultural sector

Md. Sazedul Islam :Agriculture is the lifeline of the economy of Bangladesh and the single largest sector contributing more than 16% to national GDP. According to Agriculture Information Service,

Why marriages fail

Why marriages fail

Harriet Lerner Ph.D. :With marriage having a fifty percent no-go rate it's obvious that people don't follow their best thinking, just like people don't eat healthfully even when they

Poverty elimination through women empowerment

Poverty elimination through women empowerment

Reza Mahmud :Widows have overcome adversaries with the small donation taken from a NGO in the Lalmonirhat district's Aditmari upazila. Some of them built poultry and cows fattening farms

Managing emotions for good health

Managing emotions for good health

Dr. Forqan Uddin Ahmed :Feeling, fear, emotion are human instincts. All men are devien with such instincts. Feeling arises from brain and it transmits through the process of transformation,

When is it emotional abuse?

When is it emotional abuse?

Andrea Mathews LPC, NCC :We hear the term emotional abuse tossed about quite a bit these days. So, lest we make it a dumping ground for every negative emotional

Self-development workshop for underprivileged women in city

Self-development workshop for underprivileged women in city

Rabiul Alam :Oxfam Bangladesh and Dustha Shasthya Kendra (DSK) jointly hosted a workshop titled "Network meeting with local government and women Development related organizations" under the project "Empowering Women

Free eye camps in city, Raipur

Free eye camps in city, Raipur

Life Desk :Two free eye camps for the underprivileged people were held at New Castle International School premises in Jatrabari in the city and at Raipur Union Parishad Bhavan,

Maternal exposure of asthma in babies

Maternal exposure of asthma in babies

Life Desk :Babies born to mothers who got exposed to pollen during the last trimester may be at increased risk of developing respiratory diseases such as asthma, says a