Tuesday, July 17, 2018 | ePaper

Four judges of India's top court criticize its functioning

  • Print


(L-R) Justices Kurian Joseph, Jasti Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi and Madan Lokur address the media at a news conference in New Delhi, India January 12, 2018.

NEW DELHI (Reuters) :
Four justices of India's top court on Friday criticized its distribution of cases to judges and raised concerns about judicial appointments, in an unprecedented public airing of problems at one of the country's most respected institutions.
The move spells far-reaching implications for jurists and politicians in the chaotic South Asian democracy where the Supreme Court often sets the agenda on matters of policy and orders measures taken in the public interest. Exposing a rift with Chief Justice Dipak Misra, some of the Supreme Court's most senior judges told a news conference the issues involving its administration were serious enough to prompt them to go public.
"The four of us are convinced that unless this institution is preserved and it maintains its equanimity, democracy will not survive in this country," Justice Jasti Chelameswar said on the lawns of his residence in the Indian capital. The justices gave few details of the incidents they were referring to, but released          
a letter they had written to Misra. In the letter, they mentioned instances of cases with "far-reaching consequences for the nation and the institution" that were selectively assigned by the chief justice without any rational "basis for such assignment". All Supreme Court judges should be involved in setting the procedures used to hire and promote judges in various courts in the country, including the high courts, they added. Reuters could not immediately reach the chief justice for comment. Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad declined to comment.
Two close aides of Prime Minister Narendra Modi said he was looking into the matter and had summoned top law ministry officials for consultations. Some Supreme Court lawyers praised the justices' action.
"Looking at its own flaws is the first step to correcting an institution, to deepening true constitutional democracy," said Karuna Nundy, a Supreme Court lawyer. The Supreme Court has 25 judges appointed by India's president, including the chief justice, and each retires at the age of 65, the court says on its website.
The four justices at Friday's news conference - besides Chelameswar, they included Ranjan Gogoi, Madan Lokur and Kurian Joseph - are the most senior after Misra. Three of them are scheduled to retire this year, while Gogoi is in line to be the next chief justice, based on seniority. Efforts to alert the chief justice that certain things were not in order and that remedial measures were needed had failed, prompting the news conference, Chelameswar said.

More News For this Category

Nawaz, Maryam, Safdar file appeals against imprisonment verdict

Dawn.com :Former prime minister Nawaz Sharif, his daughter Maryam Nawaz, and son-in-law retired Captain Mohammad Safdar challenged their convictions by an accountability court in the Avenfield corruption reference in the

Punish attackers of teachers, students

Punish attackers of teachers, students

Staff Reporter :Students at Dhaka, Jahangirnagar and Rajshahi Universities yesterday held human chain and protested attack by ruling party student activists on students and teachers in Dhaka University campus on

Another Quota reformist missing

Staff Reporter :Quota reformist leader Tarek Rahman was being followed by plainclothes men before he went missing on Saturday, his parents have claimed.Tarek's parents Abdul Latif and Shahana Begum brought

Police in dark about killing

Staff Reporter :Police are still in a dark about the killing of the ruling party's youth front Jubo League (JL) activist Kazi Rashed in the city's Mohakhali area early Sunday.The

Apparels usher new hopes

Kazi Zahidul Hasan  :Bangladesh's exports to Indian increased by 30 per cent in the just concluded fiscal year on account of apparel products' sturdy performance, which enjoys duty-free access to

 US seeks better ties with Russia

US seeks better ties with Russia

US President Donald Trump has said that getting on with Russia is "a good thing, not a bad thing" at the start of his first summit with Vladimir Putin.Mr Trump

5 'kidnappers' held, victim rescued

Staff Reporter :Law enforcers arrested five suspects from Kamarpara of Uttara in the capital on Sunday night on charge of kidnapping a Sales Representative of Shah Cement Company from the

IOM assures BD of total support

Diplomatic Correspondent  :Director General of the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) William Lacy Swing on Monday said that the IOM would extend all kinds of support to Bangladesh for the

Hajj agencies' irregularities under ACC radar

UNB, Dhaka :Some hajj agencies in the country have indulged into gross irregularities in the name of sending people to the yearly hajj pilgrimage. Some of the irregularities were

HC orders to dispose of case against Destiny officials by Apr 18

BSS, Dhaka :The High Court (HC) on Sunday ordered the trial court concerned to dispose of case against officials of Destiny-2000 Ltd, including its managing director Rafikul Amin, by