Wednesday, October 18, 2017 | ePaper

India can`t mistreat refugees, says HRW

  • Print
Staff Reporter :
Human Rights Watch on Monday condemned the Indian authorities for "mistreating" the Rohingya refugees and said that the country had no rights to conduct such behaviour.
 "If India had not signed the Convention against torture, would Indian authorities have carte blanche to torture and ill-treat anyone in custody? Of course, not," said Bill Frelick, HRW's refugee rights programme director in a statement on Monday.
India's Home Minister, Rajnath Singh, said in a tweet that his government was "not violating any international law" if it deports Rohingya refugees "as we are not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention."
He said, India knows well that certain principles of international law are considered customary international law - they are unlawful because states have long prohibited the practice as a matter of law.    "It doesn't matter whether or not the country has ratified a treaty on the subject," Bill Frelick said adding and, if it is wrong to torture or persecute someone, forcing someone to return to a place where they face these abuses is also unacceptable.
Rajnath Singh correctly cites the 1951 Refugee Convention as a source of law for the principle of "nonrefoulement," which prohibits the return of refugees "in any manner whatsoever" to places where their lives or freedom would be threatened.
 "He (Rajnath Singh) could also have cited the 1984 Convention Against Torture, which prohibits the return of anyone to another country where there are substantial risk of torture."
There are also other regional conventions and declarations that endorse the principle, such as the 1969 OAU Refugee Convention, the 1969 American Convention on Human Rights, and the 1966 Bangkok Principles on Status and Treatment of Refugees.
 "But that's not the end of the story."
Certain rules of customary international law are so important that no government can violate them, even if a treaty existed that would allow them to do so.
The prohibitions on torture and slavery are such "peremptory norms." As early as 1982, the executive committee of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, which is composed of 101 countries including India, affirmed that the principle of nonrefoulement was "progressively acquiring the character of a peremptory rule of international law."
The Indian government says it is worried about the entry of refugees with links to Rohingya militants.
If that's the case, they should produce evidence and prosecute individual suspects.
While a Rohingya militant group attacked security posts in Myanmar, it is the campaign of ethnic cleansing by the Myanmar military that has caused Rohingya to flee, most to Bangladesh but some to India.
 "When your neighbor flees his burning house, you are not at liberty to push him back into the flames because you consider him a trespasser," Bill Frelick said.
 "The Rohingya are literally fleeing their burning homes. The obligation not to push them back stems less from a signature on a piece of paper than from the fundamental principles of our shared humanity."

More News For this Category

Save Rohingyas, they have not come to Bangladesh to die

Diplomatic Correspondent :The exodus of Rohingya refugees sees no end as the Myanmar army is running its ethnic cleansing operation to free the Rakhine State to create an all

Pakistan EC suspends 261 lawmakers for non-disclosure of financial statements

Dawn.com :The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) on Monday suspended the membership of 261 lawmakers for failure to submit details of their finances under sub-section 42A of the Representation of

President should not have asked the judges -- Barrister Mainul

Staff Reporter :At a talk-show called ‘Muktabak’ of News-24 TV on Monday night Barrister Mainul Hosein said he could not believe that the judges of the Appellate Division of

Hospital: Mission for making money

Staff Reporter :An expecting mother was allegedly driven away by staff members of a maternity clinic in the city as she failed to give them the money they demanded for

15,000 refugees stranded near border UN urges BD to speed up vetting

15,000 refugees stranded near border UN urges BD to speed up vetting

The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) urged Bangladesh on Tuesday to speed up vetting of about 15,000 Rohingya refugees "stranded" near the border after they cross into the country and move

Mass destruction of Rohingya homes in Rakhine

Newly released satellite images revealed that at least 288 villages were destroyed by fire in northern Rakhine State in Myanmar since August 25.According to Human Rights Watch (HRW), the destruction

IOM to help relocate Rohingyas to Bhasan Char

The International Organization for Migration (IOM) has assured the government of providing all sorts of assistance in shifting Rohingyas to Bhasan Char in Noakhali, said a minister."Kulupalong camp, located on

UN report on hunger is shelved at Myanmar's request

Staff Reporter :The United Nations food aid agency withdrew a critical report revealing desperate hunger among the persecuted Rohingya population after the Myanmar government demanded it be taken down, according

Zakir Hossain to act as SC RG

Staff Reporter :Registrar of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court (SC) Md Zakir Hossain on Tuesday had been designated as the Acting Registrar General of the SC.He will perform

Unicef wants addl funding

Unicef on Tuesday said it will not be able to continue providing lifesaving aid and protection to the Rohingya children who have fled horrific violence in Myanmar for refuge in