Sunday, November 19, 2017 | ePaper

G20's record does not inspire hope

  • Print
Anis Chowdhury and Jomo Kwame Sundaram :
The G20 leaders meeting in Hamburg, Germany, on 7-8 July comes almost a decade after the grouping's elevation to meeting at the heads of state/government level. Previously, the G20 had been an informal forum of finance ministers and central bank governors from advanced and emerging economies created in 1999 following the 1997-1998 Asian financial crisis.
Expectations of the Hamburg G20 summit are now quite modest, and there is greater media and public interest in the bilateral meetings around the event. It is a sad reminder that needed reforms to improve the world economy and the welfare of its people are unlikely to come from the G20, and tragically, from any other quarter for some time to come.
The new grouping's record in steering the global economy since the first summit in Washington, DC in November 2008 after the global financial crisis (GFC) was acknowledged by financial markets to have begun a couple of months before.
London Summit's high point
At the following April 2009 London Summit, hosted by Gordon Brown, the G20 leaders demonstrated unprecedented solidarity in confronting the global meltdown with financial packages for the IMF, World Bank and others worth USD1.1 trillion. The London financial package included USD250 billion to help developing countries secure trade finance in the face of financial uncertainty.
These measures succeeded in turning the tide, with world economic growth recovering robustly from minus 2.1% in 2009 to plus 4.1% in 2010, exceeding the pre-crisis 2007 level of 3.8%. G20 boosters are inclined to claim that the London Summit pulled the global economy from the cusp of the first post-Second World War "great depression".
However, there has been little evidence of how the funds may have saved the world economy. There has been modest trade growth since 2008 - after earlier sustained trade expansion - as most G20 member countries introduced essentially 'protectionist' trade measures despite their declared commitment to the contrary. The leaders also agreed to develop new financial regulations and improve financial supervision, but the patchwork which emerged has had limited and mixed consequences.
Toronto U turn
G20 leadership, evident at the April 2009 London summit, was abdicated with its U turn at the June 2010 Toronto summit while claiming success for its earlier collective efforts. The Canadian hosts trumpeted its own strong recovery from around -3% in 2009 to +3% in 2010 as the G20 exaggerated hints of recovery to pave the way for 'fiscal consolidation' instead.
Expectations of the Hamburg G20 summit are now quite modest, and there is greater media and public interest in the bilateral meetings around the event. It is a sad reminder that needed reforms to improve the world economy and the welfare of its people are unlikely to come from the G20, and tragically, from any other quarter for some time to come.
Canada received strong support from Germany and Japan which also claimed strong recoveries. Further support came from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the European Central Bank (ECB) which invoked the 'expansionary fiscal consolidation hypothesis' to claim that urgent U turns would boost investor confidence to sustain economic recovery.
The U turn from Keynesian-style debt-financed fiscal stimulus measures deprived the modest recovery of the means for sustaining renewed expansion, thus ensuring the GFC's 'Great Recession', which has dragged on in much of the North for almost a decade since, dragging down world and developing country growth in recent years.
Recession self-inflicted
Despite warnings from the United Nations and a few others against premature fiscal consolidation, G20 leaders at the Toronto Summit agreed to cut budget deficits in half by 2013, and to eliminate deficits altogether by 2016! The decision triggered a double dip recession in Japan and some Eurozone countries.
Canada and Germany, which pushed for rapid fiscal consolidation, have since experienced significantly slower growth averaging 1.8% and 1.2% respectively. The global economy thus began a prolonged period of anaemic growth averaging around 2.5% per annum.
Clearly, G20 economic growth continues to be modest. They are still unable to attain the 2010 growth rate, giving the lie to the 'expansionary fiscal consolidation' claim. The IMF has since acknowledged that its initial recommendation of rapid fiscal consolidation was based on "back of the envelope" calculations!
Research also shows that fiscal consolidation has exacerbated income inequality while fiscal consolidation basically began once financial sectors had been rescued from the consequences of their own greedy operations.
Lack of accountability to the rest of the world has also meant that the G20 continues to undermine multilateralism. Inclusive multilateralism is now being threatened on many other fronts as well, not least by the Trumpian turn in the White House and the growing tendency for the Europeans to act as a bloc.
The G20's broader membership has made negotiations and consultations more difficult than those involving the G7 grouping of major developed economies. But its greater inclusion and diversity has also ensured its superior record compared to the G7, which continues to decline in relevance.
As the Toronto U turn and its devastating legacy remind us, the G20's finest moment after its London summit in 2009 was easily reversed through host country efforts although the US and China were acting quite differently in practice.
Expectations of the Hamburg G20 summit are now quite modest, and there is greater media and public interest in the bilateral meetings around the event. It is a sad reminder that needed reforms to improve the world economy and the welfare of its people are unlikely to come from the G20, and tragically, from any other quarter for some time to come.

Courtesy: IPS

More News For this Category

Bio-diversity in Sundarbans faces severe threat from pollution

RAPIDLY increasing air and water pollution threw pollinators in the Sunderbans on the verge of extinction threatening the world's largest mangrove forest's flora. Severe air and water pollution caused

Engage the dignitaries for a prompt multilateral approach

FIVE foreign ministers from top Asian and European countries including a few high-ups of the European Union have started arriving in Dhaka since yesterday for discussing the Rohingya crisis

Unsafe roads cost 5pc of global GDP growth

Paul Callan and Karim Aziz :From New Delhi to Cairo, pedestrians and drivers have long suffered from poor road conditions with dangerous consequences. According to the World Health Organization, more

Economic development Vs Climate action

Friday Phiri  :As negotiators meet in Bonn to put together a deal to implement the Paris Agreement, John Holdren, a professor of environmental policy at the John F. Kennedy School

Paradise papers highlight the link between grand-scale corruption and poverty

Tutu Alicante :A French court's decision on 27 October to convict (in abstentia) Teodoro Nguema Obiang Mangue (commonly known as "Teodorin"), the vice-president of Equatorial Guinea (who happens to be

Readers’ Forum

WC Football 2018The four Asian representatives in the galaxy of 32 in the World Cup (WC) Football 2018 are Iran, Japan, Saudi Arabia and South Korea. The fifth one Australia

Questions over holding tax

THE government moves to increase holding tax in Dhaka and Chittagong cities by up to nine times at a time seems to be highly arbitrary that lacks reasonable justification

Most of the world officially unites against Myanmar, now it's time for action

IN a landmark event, the OIC's draft resolution of the Rohigya crisis was passed at the United Nations on Thursday. Some 171 countries of the UN's Third Committee actively

Readers’ Forum

We are feeling lost :As a citizen of Bangladesh, I think it is my sacred duty to speak out about issues, which are harmful for the country. It is

The Mekong, dammed to die

Pascal Laureyn :In Laos, the lush forests are alive with the whines of drills that pierce the air. On the Mekong, a giant concrete wall rises slowly above the